Salted Caramel & Bourbon Milkshake

This Salted Caramel & Bourbon Milkshake is a specialty at Ted’s Montana Grill…and now you can make it at home! Vanilla ice cream, bourbon and caramel; it’s amazing!

Boozy Salted Caramel Milkshake served in a tall glass, drizzled with caramel and topped with whipped cream and a cherry.

I am occasionally the lucky recipient of an invitation to visit a local restaurant and try some of their menu items, and most recently a visit included this amazing Salted Caramel & Bourbon Milkshake. Obviously not at all in the same way a food critic would sample dishes but as a guest.

Their hopes are that I will enjoy a meal and share it with my readers and my sincere hope is that I will too. It does seem the cards in the deck are stacked in their favor, after all they know why I am there so of course they pull out all the stops; does make you wonder if it’s a fair representation of what a diner could expect right?

Want to save this recipe?

Enter your email & I’ll send it to your inbox. Plus, get great new recipes from me every week!

My most recent invitation was to visit one of Ted Turner’s restaurants aptly named Ted’s Montana Grill which has several locations in the Denver metro area. This would be fun and easy…my kids took me there for my birthday and we loved it!

While the memory of the Canyon Creek Burger had me over the moon, I knew as soon as I took a sip of dessert that it would be the one recipe I would beg the establishment for.

I decry the use of the word swoon used so often by people that it has lost any meaning but in this case, this simple dessert was absolutely swoon-worthy. Exactly how I felt when I first sipped this Salted Caramel & Bourbon Milkshake!

I fondly remember that first time I went to a Ted’s Montana Grill. They had just recently opened their establishment on Larimer Square in downtown Denver.

My girls wanted to take me there so it was a big night out for us. Larimer Square is a charming, bustling block in the heart of Denver; the ever present overhead twinkling lights add an extra element of gaiety and the fact that my birthday is two weeks before Christmas meant things were really popping.

Funny I don’t recall what I had that night but I will never forget what my daughter Lauren ordered and is still her favorite, the Kitchen Sink burger which includes American cheese, ham, bacon, grilled onions, mushrooms and a fried egg. The name is clearly perfect.

Since that night, they have opened a couple of other locations and I chose to go to one closer to me in my old stomping grounds of Greenwood Village in the Landmark Shopping Center. Good call…loved the proprietor and staff.

I had invited a friend to join me and Rajean decided to order the St. Phillip’s Island Crab Cakes which boasted a Southwestern seasoning, guacamole, roasted asparagus and kale salad. I am a big fan of seafood and was sorely tempted to follow her lead. I had a certain ping of envy but that was silly; we’re all about sharing!

I remembered Lauren’s love of their burger so I went that direction and chose one that was a bit unique and seriously the PERFECT choice for me. The Canyon Creek Burger includes Cheddar cheese, bacon, jalapeno, blackberry jam and a fried egg. I buy a local jam that is blackberry with serrano peppers and I simply love that sweet/hot combination so felt good with this choice and I was not wrong.

The burger I enjoyed on my birthday was bison, so this time around I opted for beef. Juicy enough that I had to remain watchful and not embarrass myself with rivers of deliciousness running down my shirt and a flavor combination that was everything I had hoped for. I thought this was really the Kitchen Sink and more. So much more that I could barely make it through half even after sharing some with Rajean.

The proprietor at this location was great. Not just attentive but warm and friendly too. He shared some of his personal path towards ending up at Ted’s and his enthusiasm for the company was palpable. He told us how involved Mr. Turner is with the business and that ‘Aunt Fannie’s’ Squash Casserole is really and truly his aunt’s dish. Rajean wasn’t sure she had ever had a squash casserole before and within minutes a sample appeared for her to try.

A short story about how they hand cut and make all of their onion rings daily and again, magically, a plate appeared for us to try. My kind of rings; onions tender enough to bite through and a crispy seasoned crust to die for. Dipped in some of their horseradish sauce? Heaven.

We were full and content and I believe I might have even inquired about a cot when Kyle asked if we would like some dessert. Oh how I love dessert but we were so full we couldn’t so of course we did. You know just not to be rude. 🙂

Highly recommended was their Strawberry Shortcake, delivered in a tall stack with house made drop biscuits, vanilla ice cream, fresh strawberry sauce and whipped cream. It reminded me of what I make for my family with the drop biscuits and the truth is it was enough for a family on that one plate!

Loved it. It really was enough for a crowd and we were full so…oh shoot who am I kidding? We ate it all. Good thing we were sharing

BUT, but, but…nothing prepared me for the Salted Caramel & Bourbon Milkshake listed under ‘Adult Shakes.’ Oh my. Simple too…which is why I requested (OK, begged) for the recipe. Please, please, please???

Old fashioned milkshake machine with ingredient for salted caramel milkshake.

No secret I love using bourbon in desserts but often there is just the slight hint. This was no hint. This was a for real bourbon kick. Rajean and I are adults but I think there might have been a bit of ‘no it’s MINE’ going on…it really was heavenly.

I had already imagined including this Salted Caramel & Bourbon Milkshake in these pages and have been anxious to share but well, the Kentucky Derby really does require a Mint Julep so patience was required.

Now the day is here, the Derby will be run in a couple of hours and I can publish this amazingly delicious mixture of simple ingredients. Easy to make too. OK, maybe you won’t have your own milkshake machine (yay for garage sales!) but a blender will do nicely. While I did make my own caramel sauce (and added 2 tablespoons of bourbon to it) you do not have to and sometimes I don’t either.

Just buy a good brand at the grocery store; I’ve used this Ghirardelli Salted Caramel Sauce and it’s good! Do try making your whipped cream using brown sugar; it’s great with the bourbon.

Tall milkshake glass filled with a vanilla ice cream mixed with bourbon and salted caramel, topped with whipped cream and more salted caramel.

Ted’s Salted Caramel & Bourbon Milkshake features Jack Daniel’s whiskey but I used my favorite everyday bourbon, Makers Mark. As long as you include some good vanilla bean ice cream and caramel the spirit is up to you. Still, the real bottom line?

You must try this. I saved some for Amy, my neighbor across the street. She of the, ‘not sure I love bourbon’ type? Well in less than a week I’ve got her loving Mint Juleps and this shake….how do you like bourbon now my dear??

If you’re in Denver and close to the Tech Center? Make your reservation now to visit Ted’s Montana Grill; while I love re-creating some of their favorites at home, there is nothing quite like visiting them for a special experience.

More of Our Favorite Ice Cream Treats

Boozy Favorites

Beer Float and Milkshakes

Favorite Ice Creams

Sauces/Toppings

PIN IT! ‘Salted Caramel & Bourbon Milkshake’